With 12 colors available, the NYX Micro Brow Pencil has one of the best shade ranges we found. Taupe is often good for blondes unless you're purposefully going for a darker brow. 'Anything darker tends to look a bit more dramatic,' he adds. To achieve a more natural look, Peña says it's best to choose a pencil that's too light rather than too dark.

Shade: Brunettes should opt for a color that's one shade lighter than your natural eyebrow hairs.What to Look For in a Drugstore Eyebrow Pencil We also consulted a celebrity makeup artist for product expert recommendations and insight into choosing eyebrow products.Īttributes we evaluated each drugstore eyebrow pencil on: We also tried out several pencils ourselves to see how they helped up in the real world. To compile this list, our team of editors and contributors spent hours researching the best drugstore eyebrow pencils currently on the market, evaluating each product based on shade range, tip size and shape, waterproofness, and wear time.

Instant Lift Brow Pencil which stands up to high-end brow pencils we've used. Interested in something even more affordable? You can't go wrong with the e.l.f. Perfect for defining and filling in your brows, it has a super-fine tip that never needs to be sharpened and a built-in spoolie for brushing and blending. Overall, our favorite drugstore eyebrow pencil is CoverGirl's Easy Breezy Brow Micro-Fine + Define Pencil. We also took several for a spin and asked makeup artists for their favorite products to help us put together this list of all-stars below. We searched high and low to find the best drugstore eyebrow pencils, evaluating each for its shade range, tip, spoolie, wear time, and price. There's no need to drop big bucks on this makeup product, though. 'For example,' he says, ' enhancing your brows and completely changing your brow shape require different pencils.' A few swipes will define, shape, and fill out your brows-no microblading necessary.Īccording to celebrity makeup artist Dillion Peña, you'll want to look for not only the right color for your complexion when buying a brow pencil but also the right size and shape of the tip for the result you're looking to achieve. Whether you rock bold, beautiful Zendaya-like brows or thinner, more delicate arches, nearly all of our brows could use a little assist from an eyebrow pencil. If your eyes are the window to your soul, consider your eyebrows the window treatments-the feature that defines your entire face.

Eyebrow pencil covergirl